Worksheet #4

Answering the How, Why, and Where questions

It’s time now to conduct substantial research into your corporation. You’re going to tackle a number of issues, so give yourself plenty of time.

I. Work out why your TNC is globalizing:

• Is it to reach a bigger market (‘market access’)?
• Or is it to produce goods more cheaply (‘sourcing efficiency’)?
• Or is it both of these ?
• Or has the TNC always been globally organized because of its product e.g. oil?

A. If the TNC is globalizing to reach a bigger global market, investigate how it’s trying to expand its market share. Make two lists:

What investments (new retail outlets, new supply chains etc) is it developing?

What countries is it targeting as future markets for sales?

 

B. If your TNC is globalizing in order to produce goods more cheaply (‘sourcing effeciency’), try to identify what parts of the production process it is off-shoring and to where.

 

Production process                                                     Where?

 

II. In what way has your TNC globalized?

Determine if the following 4 general TNC globalization methods/patterns have determined the global expansion of your TNC and write a few sentences about the details (for example, specifically what kind of facility or contract, when it was established, where, etc.)

 

A. FDI - foreign direct investment in everything from retailing outlets to new factories and new offices (common in producer driven commodity chains)

B. Mergers and acquisitions of foreign companies

C. Market-mediated contractual ties with foreign vendors, franchises and producers (common in market-driven commodity chains)

D . Sales expansion overseas finding new markets and/or adapting products for foreign markets

 

III. Have you missed anything?

Use Dunning’s paradigm chart to evaluate if you have something left out.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Dunning's Chart

 


Types of international production

(O)

Ownership advantages (the “why” of MNE activity)

(L)

Location advantages (the “where” of production)

(I)

Internalization advantages (the “how” of involvement)

Strategic(s) goals of MNEs

Illustration of types of activity that favour MNEs

Natural resource seeking

Capital, technology, access to markets, complementary assets; size and negotiating strengths

Possession of natural resources and related transport and communications infrastructure; tax and other incentives

To ensure stability of supplies at right price; control markets

To gain privileged access to resources vis-á-vis competitors

(a) Oil, copper, bauxite, bananas, pineapples, cocoa, hotels

(b) Export processing labour-intensive products or processes

Market seeking

1) Determine what kind of production your TNC is involving in overseas

 

Capital, technology, information, management and organizational skills; surplus R&D and other capacity, economies of scale, ability to generate brand loyalty

Material and labour costs; market size and characteristics; government policy (a.g. with respect to regulations and to import controls, investment incentives, etc.)

Wish to reduce transaction or information costs, buyer ignorance or uncertainly, etc.., to protect property rights

To protect existing markets, counteract behavior of competitors; to preclude rivals or potential rivals from gaining new markets

Computers, pharmaceuticals, motor vehicles, cigarettes, processed foods, airline services

Efficiency seeking (a) of product (b) of processes

 

As above, but also access to markets; economies of scope, geographical diversification and international sourcing of inputs

(a) Economies of product specialization and concentration

(b) Low labour costs; incentives to local production by host governments

(a) As for second category plus gains from economies of common governance

(b) The economies of vertical integration and horizontal diversification

As part of regional or global product rationalization and/or to gain advantages of process specialization

(a) Motor vehicles, electrical appliances, business services, some R&D

(b) Consumer electronics, textiles and clothing, cameras, pharmaceuticals

Strategic asset seeking

Any of first three that offer opportunities for synergy with existing assets

Any of first three that offer technology, markets and other assets in which firm is deficient

Economies of common governance; improved competitiveness to gain new product lines or market

To strengthen global innovatory or production competitiveness; to gain new product lines or markets

Industries that record a high ratio of fixed to overhead costs and which offer substantial economies of scale or synergy

Trade and distribution (import and export merchanting)

Market access; products to distribute

Source of inputs and local markets; need to be near customers; after-sales servicing, etc.

Need to protect quality of inputs; need to ensure sales outlets and to avoid underperformance or misrepresentation by foreign agents

Either as entry to new markets or as part of regional or global marketing strategy

A variety of goods, particularly those requiring contact with subcontractors and final consumers

Support services

Experience of clients in home countries

Availability of markets, particularly those of “lead” clients

Various (see above categories

As part of regional or global product or geographical diversification

(a) Accounting advertising, banking, producer goods

(b) Where spatial linkages are essential (e.g. airlines and shipping)

 

   

 

 

1) Determine what kind of production your TNC is involved in overseas.

2) Look in the first 3 columns to answer questions about “why”, “where”, and “how” the TNC is globalizing.

3) Look in the final columns for other useful things about your TNC’s motives, etc.

 

IV. To Turn in:

1) Prepare a map depicting the extent of the corporation's global scope. The places from where it sources products in one color, and the places to which it markets products in another color. You can get world and regional map templates to print out and mark-up from http://www.eduplace.com/ss/maps/

 

A quick start to Google Maps is at UCLA

Here is a PDF copy from that workshop.

DO NOT EXPECT THAT THE TNC MAPS ALREADY EXIST AND CAN BE FOUND IN THE LIBRARY. SIMPLY USE INFORMATION THAT YOU YOURSELF HAVE DISCOVERED TO SKETCH THE MAP ON THE TEMPLATES.

2) Write a 3 page report on whether the corporation is globalizing mainly for market access reasons, for sourcing efficiency reasons, or for some complex mix of the two.