Worksheet #4
Answering the How, Why, and Where questions
It’s time now to conduct substantial research into your
corporation. You’re going to tackle a number of issues, so give yourself plenty
of time.
I. Work out why your TNC is globalizing:
• Is it to reach a bigger market (‘market access’)?
• Or is it to produce goods more cheaply (‘sourcing efficiency’)?
• Or is it both of these ?
• Or has the TNC always been globally organized because of its product e.g. oil?
A. If the TNC is globalizing to reach a bigger global
market, investigate how it’s trying to expand its market share. Make two lists:
What investments (new retail outlets, new supply chains
etc) is it developing?
What countries is it targeting as future markets for sales?
B. If your TNC is globalizing in order to produce goods
more cheaply (‘sourcing effeciency’), try to identify what parts of the
production process it is off-shoring and to where.
Production process
Where?
II. In what way has your TNC globalized?
Determine if the following 4 general TNC globalization
methods/patterns have determined the global expansion of your TNC and write a
few sentences about the details (for example, specifically what kind of facility
or contract, when it was established, where, etc.)
A. FDI - foreign direct investment in everything from
retailing outlets to new factories and new offices (common in producer driven
commodity chains)
B. Mergers and acquisitions of foreign companies
C. Market-mediated contractual ties with foreign vendors,
franchises and producers (common in market-driven commodity chains)
D . Sales expansion overseas finding new markets and/or
adapting products for foreign markets
III. Have you missed anything?
Use Dunning’s paradigm chart to evaluate if you have
something left out.
Dunning's Chart |
Types of
international
production
|
(O)
Ownership
advantages (the
“why” of MNE
activity)
|
(L)
Location
advantages (the
“where” of
production)
|
(I)
Internalization
advantages (the
“how” of
involvement)
|
Strategic(s)
goals of MNEs
|
Illustration of
types of
activity that
favour MNEs
|
Natural
resource seeking
|
Capital,
technology,
access to
markets,
complementary
assets; size and
negotiating
strengths
|
Possession of
natural
resources and
related
transport and
communications
infrastructure;
tax and other
incentives
|
To ensure
stability of
supplies at
right price;
control markets
|
To gain
privileged
access to
resources
vis-á-vis
competitors
|
(a) Oil, copper,
bauxite,
bananas,
pineapples,
cocoa, hotels
(b) Export
processing
labour-intensive
products or
processes
|
Market seeking
1) Determine what kind of production your TNC is involving in overseas
|
|
|
Capital,
technology,
information,
management and
organizational
skills; surplus
R&D and other
capacity,
economies of
scale, ability
to generate
brand loyalty
|
Material and
labour costs;
market size and
characteristics;
government
policy (a.g.
with respect to
regulations and
to import
controls,
investment
incentives,
etc.)
|
Wish to reduce
transaction or
information
costs, buyer
ignorance or
uncertainly,
etc.., to
protect property
rights
|
To protect
existing
markets,
counteract
behavior of
competitors; to
preclude rivals
or potential
rivals from
gaining new
markets
|
Computers,
pharmaceuticals,
motor vehicles,
cigarettes,
processed foods,
airline services
|
Efficiency
seeking (a) of
product (b) of
processes
|
As above, but
also access to
markets;
economies of
scope,
geographical
diversification
and
international
sourcing of
inputs
|
(a) Economies of
product
specialization
and
concentration
(b) Low labour
costs;
incentives to
local production
by host
governments
|
(a) As for
second category
plus gains from
economies of
common
governance
(b) The
economies of
vertical
integration and
horizontal
diversification
|
As part of
regional or
global product
rationalization
and/or to gain
advantages of
process
specialization
|
(a) Motor
vehicles,
electrical
appliances,
business
services, some
R&D
(b) Consumer
electronics,
textiles and
clothing,
cameras,
pharmaceuticals
|
Strategic
asset seeking
|
Any of first
three that offer
opportunities
for synergy with
existing assets
|
Any of first
three that offer
technology,
markets and
other assets in
which firm is
deficient
|
Economies of
common
governance;
improved
competitiveness
to gain new
product lines or
market
|
To strengthen
global
innovatory or
production
competitiveness;
to gain new
product lines or
markets
|
Industries that
record a high
ratio of fixed
to overhead
costs and which
offer
substantial
economies of
scale or synergy
|
Trade and
distribution
(import and
export
merchanting)
|
Market access;
products to
distribute
|
Source of inputs
and local
markets; need to
be near
customers;
after-sales
servicing, etc.
|
Need to protect
quality of
inputs; need to
ensure sales
outlets and to
avoid
underperformance
or
misrepresentation
by foreign
agents
|
Either as entry
to new markets
or as part of
regional or
global marketing
strategy
|
A variety of
goods,
particularly
those requiring
contact with
subcontractors
and final
consumers
|
Support services
|
Experience of
clients in home
countries
|
Availability of
markets,
particularly
those of “lead”
clients
|
Various (see
above categories
|
As part of
regional or
global product
or geographical
diversification
|
(a) Accounting
advertising,
banking,
producer goods
(b) Where
spatial linkages
are essential
(e.g. airlines
and shipping)
|
|
|
|
1) Determine what kind of production your TNC is involved
in overseas.
2) Look in the first 3 columns to answer questions about
“why”, “where”, and “how” the TNC is globalizing.
3) Look in the final columns for other useful things about
your TNC’s motives, etc.
IV. To Turn in:
1) Prepare a map depicting the extent of the corporation's
global scope. The places from where it sources products in one color, and the
places to which it markets products in another color. You can get world and
regional map templates to print out and mark-up from
http://www.eduplace.com/ss/maps/
A quick start to Google Maps is at UCLA
Here is a PDF copy from
that workshop.
DO NOT EXPECT THAT THE TNC MAPS ALREADY EXIST AND CAN BE
FOUND IN THE LIBRARY. SIMPLY USE INFORMATION THAT YOU YOURSELF HAVE DISCOVERED
TO SKETCH THE MAP ON THE TEMPLATES.
2) Write a 3 page report on whether the corporation is
globalizing mainly for market access reasons, for sourcing efficiency reasons,
or for some complex mix of the two.