John Brown Legacy Lesson Plan
By Brian Krause
TAH Grant 2009-2010
Timetable: 2-3 class
periods
Grades: High School
Objectives: For
students to dig deeper and gain a better understanding of John Brown,
the raid on Harper’s Ferry, VA, and the subsequent end to John Brown’s
life and the legacy that followed.
Materials Needed –
The following primary source materials:
*Brantz
Mayer Visit to Harper’s Ferry
*John
Brown to Mass. Legislature
*John
Brown Song
*NY
Tribune article on execution
*Free
State Kansas Fund
*John
Brown to NY Tribune 1857
*John
Brown Southern Reaction
*State
Aide for Kansas
*Independent
Democrat Articles on the Raid
*John
Brown Brief Letters
*John
Brown to Mary Ann Brown 1859
Also
needed: poster board, colored pencils, rulers
Lesson Description:
1.)
Class will be divided into groups of 5 students or smaller
2.)
Each group will be given copies of the above primary source documents
3.)
Each group will look at the documents by first having each student read at
least 2 of the primary source documents and then teaching what they
have learned about the documents to other members of the group
4.)
After students are familiar with all of the information in the documents an
entire class discussion will be held to check for understanding and
answer any questions/fill in any gaps in student understanding
5.)
Students will then be creating a 10-slide storyboard on John Brown’s life
showing the progression of events in his life and the reaction that was
seen after his execution, students will also include their thought as to
whether John Brown was a hero or a villain and why – each group member will be
responsible for creating at least 2 of the slides
6.)
Groups will present storyboards to the rest of the class when completed
Assessment: Students
will be graded based on a rubric consisting of group
John Brown Legacy Documents
Brantz Mayer Visit to Harpers Ferry,
1856
“The Potomac, at this
point, is a third of a mile wide, and foams over a bed of ledges crossing it at
right angles like so many fractured barriers, denoting the conflict between the
ridge and river when it burst through the hills. Such, with few intermissions,
is the character of scenery from the Point of Rocks to Harper’s Ferry, which is
built on a narrow, declivitous tongue, lying directly in the confluence of the
Shenandoah and Potomac, and washed on either side by those noble streams. The
railway reaches it by a stupendous curving bridge of nine hundred feet over the
latter; and as the mountain steeps converge precipitously at all points about
the gap, but small space is left for building with accessible convenience.
Nearly all the level river-margin has been used for the National Armory, so
that the town scrambles picturesquely among the upland bluffs, till the
hill-top, like the end of all things, is terminated by the groves and monuments
of a cemetery.
Our first visit was
to the Armory, where we were introduced to all the mysteries in this wonderful
assemblage of contrivances for death. Every thing was exhibited and set in
motion—from the ponderous tilt-hammers, which weld steel into solidity, down to
the delicate operations by which the impulse of a hair can put these terrible
engines in action. I was soon struck by the fact that, after all, it is not so
easy to kill a man—especially, if we consider the intricate preparations which
have to be made in constructing weapons for human slaughter. We learned that a
musket consists of forty-nine pieces, and that the number of operations in
completing one—each of which is separately catalogued and valued—amount to
three hundred and forty-six; all, in some degree, requiring different trades
and various capacities for execution; so that, perhaps, no man, or no two men
in the establishment, could perform the whole of them in manufacturing a
perfect weapon!
I confess that, with
but little turn for mechanical science, most of these complicated machines were
rather surprising than comprehensible to me; so that, while my companions
strolled through the apartments in quest of instruction, I followed leisurely
in their rear, rather grieving than glorying in the inventive skill that had
been lavished on their construction under national auspices. It may be
considered more sentimental than practical in the present belligerent state of
mankind, to doubt the wisdom of making military preparations under the amiable
name of “defense,” yet I have never been able to understand why it
should not be “constitutional” to create as well as to kill, and to make a
sickle as well as a sword! Why it is that political law allows millions for the
belongings of war, and denies a dollar to those genial arts which, in ten
years, would do more for the progress of humanity than centuries of traditionary
force have effected for its demoralization? Nay, how much more beneficially
would these hundreds of workmen be employed, if government devoted their labor
to the manufacture of such unpicturesque instruments as hoes, spades, rakes,
axes, pitchforks, plows, and reaping machines; and if the army, which is to
wield the perilous weapons that are strewn in every direction, were transmuted,
under national patronage, into cultivators of those “homesteads” which
politicians so cheaply vote them! But, alas! the soldier is epic, and the
farmer only pastoral, and pageantry beats homeliness all the world over!
These lackadaisical
fancies floated through my mind as I walked over the half mile or armory; and I
hope I may not be set down as “too progressive” or “Utopian,” if I divulge them
in this public confessional.
It was noon when we
left the Armory and climbed to the fragment of Jefferson’s Rock, which affords
the best coup d’oeil of this celebrated scenery. It was a fatiguing
tramp under a mid-day sun, but we found a breeze singing down the gorge of the
Shenandoah when we rested under the old pine-tree among the cliffs. The rock
itself is of very little interest, except for its association with Mr.
Jefferson’s name, and its remarkable poise on a massive base. The drawing at
the beginning of this article presents an accurate view of the whole scene.
From the gap between the fragments the prospect combines the grand and
beautiful in a wonderful degree. Beyond the brow of the hill very little of the
town is seen to disfigure the original features of the prospect, so that the
wilderness of mountain, forest, and water may still be as freshly enjoyed as
they were by the earliest travelers. Indeed it is impossible for language to
sketch the spirit of the spot more vividly than is done in the bold penciling
of Jefferson. “You stand,” says he, “on a very high point of land; on your
right comes up the Shenandoah, having ranged the foot of the mountain a hundred
miles to seek a vent; on your left approaches the Potomac in quest of a passage
also. In the moment of their junction they rush together against the mountain,
rend it asunder, and pass off to the sea.” In a few distinct words of outline
we have the geology and geography of the spot before us; but when the sun is
lower and the shadows broader than at the time of our visit, so as to impart
variety of tone and effect to the scene, it is difficult to conceive a wilder
prospect than the mountains forming the gap, or a more placid landscape than
that which waves away beyond it, till hill, forest, and river fade in the east.
There is a remarkable contrast between the roughness of the foreground and the
pastoral quiet of the distance, so that the very landscape seems to teach the
need and harmony of repose after struggle.
Source: Extract from Brantz Mayer. "A June Jaunt," Harper’s New Monthly Magazine, April 1857.
John Brown to Mass. Legislature
John Brown to Mary Ann Brown
November
8, 1859
Charlestown Jefferson
Co. Va:
8th Nov 1859
Dear Wife &
Children Every One
I will begin by
saying that I have in some degree recovered from my wounds; but that I am yet
quite weak in my back & sore about my left Kidney. My appetite has been
quite good for most of the time since I was hurt. I am supplied with almost Every
thing I could desire to make me comfortable, and the little that I do lack
(some few articles of clothing which I lost) I may perhaps soon get again. I am
besides quite cheerful having (as I trust) the peace of God which passeth all
understanding" to "rule in my heart" and the testimony (in some
degree) of a good conscience that I have not lived altogether in vain. I can
trust God with both the time and the manner of my death; believing as I now do
that for me at this time to seal my testimony (for God & humanity) with my
blood, will do vastly more toward advancing the cause I have Earnestly
Endeavored to promote, than all I have done in my life before. I beg of you all
meekly and quietly to submit to this; not feeling yourselves to be in the least
degraded on that account. Remember dear wife and children all, that
Jesus of Nazareth suffered a most Excruciating death on the cross as a felon -
under the most aggravating circumstances. Think also of the prophets, and
apostles and Christians of former days, who went through greater tribulations
than you or I: and (try) to be reconciled. May God Almighty comfort all your
hearts, and soon wipe away all tears from your eyes. To him be endless praise.
Think too of the crushed millions "who have no comforter." I charge
you all - never (in your trials) to forget the griefs "of the
poor that cry and of those that have none to help them." I wrote most
Earnestly to my dear and afflicted wife not to come on for the present
at any rate. I will now give you my reasons for doing so. First it would
use up all the scanty means she has or is at all likely to have to make herself
and children comfortable hereafter. For let me tell you that the sympathy that
is now aroused in your behalf may not always follow you. There is but little
more of the romantic about helping poor widows and their children than there is
about trying to relieve poor "niggers." Again the little
comfort it might afford us to meet again, would be dearly bought by the pains
of final seperation [sic]. We must part, and I feel assured; for us to
meet under such dreadful circumstances would only add to our distress. If she
comes on here she must be only a gazing stock throughout the whole journey, to
be remarked upon in every look, word and action by all
sorts of creatures and by all sorts of papers throughout the whole
country, again it is my most decided judgement that in quietly and submissively
staying at home vastly more of generous sympathy will reach her; without
such dreadful sacrifice of feeling as she must put up with if she comes on. The
visits of one or two female friends that have come on here have produced great
Excitement which is very annoying: and they cannot possibly do me any good. O
Mary do not come, but patiently wait for the meeting (of those who love God
and their fellow men) where no seperation [sic] must follow. "They shall
go no more but forever" - I greatly long to hear from some one of you, and
to learn any thing that in any way affects your welfare. I sent you $10. the
other day; did you get it? I have also endeavored to stir up Christian friends
to visit you and write to you in your deep affliction. I have no doubt that
some of them at least will heed the call. Write to me, care of Capt. John Avis,
Charlestown Jefferson Co. Va: "Finally my beloved be of good
comfort." May all your names be "written in the Lambs book of
life" - May you all have the purifying and sustaining influence of the
Christian religion - is the Earnest prayer of your affectionate husband and
Father.
John Brown
P. S. I cannot
remember a night so dark as to have hindered the coming day: nor a storm so
furious or dreadful as to prevent the return of warm sunshine and a cloudless
sky. But beloved ones do remember that this is not your rest; that in
this world you have no abiding place or continuing city. To God and his
infinite mercy I always commend you.
Ever Yours
J. B.
To the Friends of Freedom.
New York Tribune
March 4, 1857
The undersigned,
whose individual means were exceedingly limited when he first engaged in the
struggle for liberty in Kansas, being now still more destitute, and no less
anxious than in time past to continue his efforts to sustain that cause, is
induced to make this earnest appeal to the friends of freedom throughout the
United States, in the firm belief that his call will not go unheeded. I ask all
honest lovers of liberty and human rights, both male and female, to hold up my
hands by contributions of pecuniary aid, either as counties, cities, towns,
villages, societies, churches, or individuals. I will endeavor to make a
judicious and faithful application of all such means as I may be supplied with.
Contributions may be sent in drafts to W. H. D. Callender, cashier State Bank,
Hartford, Conn. It is my intention to visit as many places as I can during my
stay in the States, provided I am first informed of the disposition of the
inhabitants to aid me in my efforts, as well as to receive my visit. Information
may be communicated to me (care of Massasoit House) at Springfield, Mass. Will
editors of newspapers friendly to the cause kindly second the measure, and also
give this some half-dozen insertions? Will either gentlemen or ladies, or both,
who love the cause, volunteer to take up the business? It is with no little
sacrifice of personal feeling that I appear in this manner before the
public.
JOHN BROWN.
Source: F. B. Sanborn, ed., The Life and Letters of John
Brown. Boston: Roberts Brothers, 1891., pp. 379-80
The John Brown Song (courtesy of West Virginia State Archives)
New York Semi-Weekly Tribune
December
6, 1859.
JOHN BROWN’S EXECUTION.
THE EXECUTION OF CAPT. BROWN
From Our Special
Correspondent.
Baltimore, Dec. 3, 1859.
Telegraphing from
Charlestown or Harper’s Ferry to The Tribune being out of the question, I am
forced to lose a day and write from this place. The execution was in the
highest degree imposing and solemn, and without disturbance of any kind. Lines
of patrols and pickets encircled the field for ten miles around, and over five
hundred troops were posted all about the gallows. At 7 o’clock in the morning
workmen began to erect the scaffold, the timber having been hauled the night
previous. At 8 troops began to arrive. Troopers were posted around the field at
fifty feet apart, and two lines of sentries further in. The troops did not form
hollow around the gallows, but were so disposed as to command every approach.
The sun shone brightly, and the picture presented to the eye was really
splendid. As each company arrived it took its alloted position. On the easterly
side were the cadets, with their right wing flanked by a detachment of men with
howitzers; on the northeast, the Richmond Grays; on the south, Company F of
Richmond; on the north, the Winchester Continentals, and, to preserve order in
the crowd, the Alexandria Rifleman and Capt. Gibson’s Rockingham Company were
stationed at the entrance gate, and on the outskirts. At 11 o’clock the
procession came in sight, and at once all conversation and noise ceased. A dead
stillness reigned over the field, and the tramp of the approaching troops alone
broke the silence. The escort of the prisoner was composed of Capt. Scott’s
company of cavalry, one company of Major Loring’s battalion of defencibles,
Capt. Williams’s Montpelier Guard, Capt. Scott’s Petersburg Grays, Company D,
Capt. Miller, of the Virginia Volunteers, and Young Guard, Capt. Rady, the
whole number the command of Col. T. P. August, assisted by Major Loring–the
cavalry at the head and rear of the column.
The prisoner sat upon
the box which contained his coffin, and, although pale from confinement, seemed
strong. The wagon in which he rode was drawn by two white horses. From the time
of leaving jail until he mounted the gallows stairs he wore a smile upon his
countenance, and his keen eye took in every detail of the scene. There was no
blenching nor the remotest approach to cowardice or nervousness. His remarks
have not been correctly reported in the Baltimore and New-York papers. As he
was leaving jail, when asked if he thought he could endure his fate, he said,
“I can endure almost anything but parting from friends; that is very hard.” On
the road to the scaffold, he said, in reply to an inquiry, “It has been a
characteristic of me from infancy not to suffer from physical fear. I have suffered
a thousand times more from bashfulness than from fear.” On entering the field
he said, as if surprised, “I see all persons are excluded from the field except
the military.” I was very near the old man, and scrutinized him closely. He
seemed to take in the whole scene at a glance, and he straightened himself up
proudly, as if to set to the soldiers an example of a soldier’s courage. The
only motion he made, beyond a swaying to and fro of his body, was that same
patting of his knees with his hands that we noticed throughout his trial and
while in jail. As he came upon an eminence near the gallows, he cast his eyes
over the beautiful landscape and followed the windings of the Blue Ridge
Mountains in the distance. He looked up earnestly at the sun and sky, and all
about, and then remarked, “This is a beautiful country. I have not cast my eye
over it before–that is, while passing through the field.” The cortege passed
half around the gallows to the east side, where it halted. The troops composing
the escort took up their assigned position, but the Petersburg Grays, as the
immediate body guard, remained as before, closely hemming in the prisoner. They
finally opened ranks to let him pass out, when, with the assistance of two men,
he descended from the wagon, bidding good by to those within it; and then, with
firm step and erect form, he strode past Jailor, Sheriff, and officers, and was
the first person to mount the scaffold steps. He then looked about him,
principally in the direction of the people, in the far distance. Then to Capt.
Avis, his jailor, he said, “I have no words to thank you for all your kindness
to me.” To Sheriff Campbell he remarked, “Let there be no more delay than is
necessary.” His black slouched hat was then removed, his elbows and ankles were
pinioned, and the white hood was drawn over his head. The Sheriff requested him
to step forward on the trap. He said, “You have put this thing over my head and
I cannot see; you must lead me.” There are eight minutes of suspense, while the
stupid cavalry are trying to find their proper position. Impatient at the
delay, Col. Scott gives the signal, Sheriff Campbell severs the rope with his
hatchet, the trap falls with a horrid screech of its hinges, and the
unfortunate man swings off into the air.
There was but one
spasmodic effort of the hands to clutch at the neck, but for nearly five
minutes the limbs jerked and quivered. He seemed to regain an extraordinary
hold upon life. One who had seen numbers of men hung before told me [he] had
never seen so hard a struggle. After the body had dangled in mid air for twenty
minutes, it was examined by the surgeons for signs of life. First the
Charlestown physicians went up and made their examination, and after them the
military surgeons, the prisoner being executed by the civil power and with
military assistance as well. To see them lifting up the arms, now powerless,
that once were so strong, and placing their ears to the breast of the corpse,
holding it steady by passing an arm around it, was revolting in the extreme.
And so the body
dangled and swung by its neck, turning to this side or that when moved by the
surgeons, and swinging, pendulum like, from the force of the south wind that
was blowing, until, after thirty-eight minutes from the time of swinging off,
it was ordered to be cut down, the authorities being quite satisfied that their
dreaded enemy was dead. The body was lifted upon the scaffold and fell into a
heap as limp as a rag. It was then put into the black walnut coffin, the body
guard closed in about the wagon, the cavalry led the van, and the mournful
procession moved off.
Throughout the whole
sad proceeding the utmost order and decorum reigned. I think that when the
prisoner was on the gallows, words in ordinary tones might have been heard all
over the forty-acre field. In less than fifteen minutes the whole military
force had left the field of execution, a dozen sentries alone, perhaps,
remaining. The townspeople having been kept at a considerable distance, and
none from the country about being allowed to approach nearer than a mile, there
were not, I think, counting soldiers and civilians, more than a thousand
spectators. A great felling of exasperation prevails in consequence of this
foolish stringency, and it is a wonder than conflicts have not arisen between
the citizens and their protectors.
John Brown, although
at times willing to argue with the local clergy upon religious matters, has
absolutely rejected all appearance of spiritual comfort at their hands, even
maintaining that those who were capable of countenancing Slavery, were not fit
to come between him and his God. The other day, he said, that instead of any
clergyman of Charlestown, if they would suffer him to be followed to the place
of execution by a family of little negro children, headed by a pious slave
mother, it would be all he would ask. The New-York Herald reports him to
have said when told that his wife could not remain with him more than three or
four hours, “I want this favor from the State of Virginia.” This is incorrect,
for with the same contemptuous independence which he has ever displayed, he
said, proudly, “Oh, I don’t ask any favors of the State of Virginia, You must
do your duty.” When the husband and wife parted, she shed some tears, but the
old hero, patting her on the shoulder, said, “Mary, this is not right. Show
that you have nerves.” She is said to have straightened herself up as if
electrified, and wept no more. The body left Charlestown under escort in the afternoon,
and at Harper’s Ferry was delivered up to Mrs. Brown.
Like a string that
snaps after great tension, the public mind at Charlestown seemed relieved the
moment that the body had been returned to the jail. The extra sentries were
called in, and people were suffered once more to pass in and out of town with
tolerable freedom. The dread is not all removed yet, however, for every night
mysterious lights are seen to shoot up, in the direction of Harper’s Ferry, which
are answered elsewhere. Despite all vigilance and search, no cause can be
assigned, and it is, therefore, believed that parties of rescuers are patiently
biding their time to take revenge, when fancied security once more prevails. It
is said that there can be no shadow of doubt that large bodies of armed men
have been hovering very near to Charlestown, and the remaining prisoners are
guarded with the most jealous vigilance. Yesterday morning orders were issued
that no more visitors shall be admitted to the prisoners, they having implored
the authorities to give them their little remaining time for reflection.
Independent Democrat Articles
on John Brown Raid
October
25, 1859
DARING ABOLITION FORAY!
OUTRAGEOUS ATTEMPT TO ABDUCT SLAVES FROM JEFFERSON COUNTY,
VIRGINIA.
The Soil of Virginia Stained with the blood of her Citizens
in Attempting to Defend their Firesides from Rapine and Robbery.
THE INFERNAL DESPERADOES CAUGHT, AND THE VENGEANCE OF AN
OUTRAGED COMMUNITY ABOUT TO BE APPEASED.
About midnight of
Sunday John Brown, with his force amounting, as they say, to 22 crossed the
Potomac Bridge with a one-horse covered wagon, containing their guns, picks
&c. They immediately seized Patrick Higgins, the watchman at the Bridge,
who gave one of the party a blow and made his escape, informing the Conductor
of the night train of Cars, Capt. Phelps. They then endeavored to induce
Hayward, the free colored watchman of the Railroad Office to take up arms and
join them in their nefarious purposes. Upon his refusing to do so, they
immediately shot him. He was a valuable fellow, whose life was worth more than all
the bandit, as he was trusted with everything in the Depot.
Sixteen of them
taking possession of the Armory and Arsenal, the others repaired to the
residence of Col. L. W. Washington, near Halltown, in this county, and after
arousing him from his bed, with pointed rifles, demanded his surrender, and
that of his negroes, &c. From thence they proceeded to the residence of Mr
John H. Alstadtt, living on the turnpike, and made a similar demand. They then
returned to Harpers Ferry, and placed their captives in the Government
Watchhouse.
The insurgents having
cut the telegraph wires, and stationed themselves at various points prevented
further entrances in the public square. Mr. Thomas Burley, being seen with a
gun was shot by a negro sentinel from the corner of one of the Arsenal
buildings. The ball passed through is body killing him almost instantly. This negro
fellow was afterwards shot.
Capt. John Avis of
this town formed a company of 20 men who were posted in front of the Arsenal. Capt.
Botts was detached with 20 volunteers, who took possession in front of the
“Galt House,” in the rear of the Arsenal. Capt. Rowan’s Guards crossed the
Potomac River and took possession of the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad Bridge.
The citizens of the place, without any regular command, took other stations of
the town, thereby cutting off all retreat.
The firing then
commenced. Capt. Avis forced the door of the Arsenal with a gun taken from the
hands of Mr. Leonard Sadler, of this town, one of the Soldiers of 1812. The
fire becoming too warm, the insurgents fled to the watch house. Before they
abandoned the Arsenal ground, and before the charge was made upon them, George
W. Turner, Esq., one of our most estimable and valuable citizens, was shot as
he was passing down High street. He died in a short time afterwards.
The citizens made
gallant charges at both works of the Armory. At the Rifle Factory the rebels
were driven into the river. One was taken prisoner and three shot. A negro man
of Col. Washington was drowned in his effort to escape. He had been forced to
take up arms.
Thus having been
driven from every point, they were virtually whipt, as none were left but those
in the watch house, who were anxious to capitulate as they were hemmed up and
cut off from every avenue of escape. Their terms of capitulation were that they
should be allowed to pass over the Bridge into Maryland with their arms. The
response of our officers was an unconditional surrender.
The insurgents had
made holes in the watch house, from which points they fired. Fontaine Beckham, Esqr,
Agent of the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad, and Mayor of Harpers Ferry, was
killed. He was on the Railroad in front of the house. About 5 o’clock the
Winchester Contine[n]tal Guards Capt B. B. Washington arrived, and were
stationed to guard the upper works. A train of cars from Frederick brought
three companies, about 100 strong.
In the morning of
Tuesday, about 3 [o]’clock, the military of Baltimore, with the Marine from
Washington, arrived so that in 28 hours from the time of alarm we had on the
ground 10 companies, numbering upwards of 400, and one company of regulars, 75
strong, besides 1500 citizens. The Alexandria Riflemen, were also present on
Tuesday.
On Tuesday morning,
Col. Lee stormed the Watch house. One of the Marines was killed, and one
slightly wounded. All the insurgents were either killed or wounded.
Out of the whole 22
as stated all have been killed or taken prisoners except Cooke and Taylor.
The negroes, who were
captured from our citizens, as soon as an opportunity was presented, made their
escape, and returned to their masters much gratified to be able to do so. It is
gratifying to know that there is not one of our negroes who would voluntarily
take up with these desperadoes
We give below the list
of those who were taken prisoners of the marauding party:--and who are now in
the Charlestown Jail—
Capt. John Brown, of
New York;
Aaron D. Stevens of Con.
Edwin Coppeck, Iowa.
Shields Green (colored) of Harrisburg Pa.
John Copeland (colored) of Obe[r]lin, Ohio.
The following is a
description of the assault upon the Engine house, as published in the Baltimore
American, whose reporter was eye-witness of the scene:
Shortly after 7
o’clock, on Tuesday morning, Lt. J. E. B. Stuart of the 1st Cavalry, who was
acting as aid for Col. Lee, advanced to parley with the besieged, Samuel
Strider, Esq., bearing a flag of truce. They were received at the door by Capt Brown—Lieut
Stuart demanded an unconditional surrender, only promising them protection from
immediate violence, and trial by law. Capt. Brown refused all terms but those
previously demanded, which were substantially: “That he should be permitted to
march out with his men and arms, taken their prisoners with them; that they
should proceed unpursued to the second toll-gate, when they were free their
prisoners. The soldiers were then at liberty to pursue and they would fight if
they could not escape.” Obviously this was refused and Lieut Stuart pressed
upon Brown his desperate position, and urged a surrender. The expostulation
though beyond ear-shot, was evidently very earnest, and the coolness of the
Lieutenant and the courage of his aged flag bearer, won warm praise.
At this moment the
interest of the scene was intense. The volunteers were arranged all around the
building, cutting off escape in every direction. The marines divided in two
squads, were ready for a dash at the door. Finally, Lieut. Stuart, having
exhausted all argument with the determined Capt. Brown, walked slowly from the
door. Immediately the signal for attack was given, and the Marines headed by
Col. Harris and Lieut. Green advanced in two lines on each side of the door.
Two powerful fellows sprang between the lines and with heavy sledge hammers
attempted to batter down the door. The door swung and swayed, but appeared to
be secured with a rope, the spring of which deadened the effect of the blows.
Failing thus to obtain a breach, the marines were ordered to fall back, and
twenty of them took hold of a ladder, some forty feet long and advancing at a
run, brought it with tremendous force against the door. At the second blow it
gave way, one leaf falling inward in a slanting position. The marines
immediately advanced to the breach, Major Russell and Lieut. Green leading. A
marine in the front fell; the firing from the interior was rapid and sharp,
they fired with deliberate aim, and for the moment the resistance was serious
and desperate enough to excite the spectators to something like a pitch of
frenzy. The next moment the marines poured in, the firing ceased, and the work
was done, whilst the cheers rang from every side, the general feeling being
that the marines had done their part admirably.
Note: Copy of article is in John Brown Scrapbook, Boyd Stutler,
folder 7, Boyd B. Stutler Collection, West Virginia State Archives.
John Brown's Last Prophecy
Charlestown, Va, 2nd, December, 1859
I John Brown am now quite
certain that the crimes of this guilty,
land: will never be purged away; but with Blood. I had as
I now think: vainly flattered myself that withought very much
bloodshed; it might be done.
(John Brown's last
letter, written on day he hanged. From "John Brown: a Biography," by
Oswald Garrison Villard.)
Letter from Mahala Doyle
Altho' vengeance is not mine, I confess that I do feel gratified to hear that
you were stopped in your fiendish career at Harper's Ferry, with the loss of
your two sons, you can now appreciate my distress in Kansas, when you then and
there entered my house at midnight and arrested my husband and two boys, and
took them out of the yard and in cold blood shot them dead in my hearing. You
can't say you done it to free slaves. We had none and never expected to own
one...My son John Doyle whose life I beged of you is now grown up and is very
desirous to be at Charlestown on the day of your execution.
(A letter sent to John
Brown while in jail. From "To Purge This Land with Blood" by Stephen
Oates.)
Letter from Frances Ellen
Watkins
Nov. 25, 1859
Dear Friend: Although the hands of Slavery throw a barrier between you and me,
and it may not be my privilege to see you in the prison house, Virginia has no
bolts or bars through which I dread to send you my sympathy...I thank you that
you have been brave enough to reach out your hands to the crushed and blighted
of my race. You have rocked the bloody Bastille; and I hope from your sad fate
great good may arise to the cause of freedom...
(A letter from Frances
Watkins, a free black living in Kendallville, Indiana. From "Freedom's
Unfinished Revolution," by William Friedheim and The American Social
History Project.)
A Plea for Capt. John
Brown
By Henry David Thoreau
I am here to plead his cause with you. I plead not for his life, but for his
character, - his immortal life; and so it becomes your cause wholly, and is not
his in the least. Some eighteen hundred years ago Christ was crucified; this
morning, perchance, Captain Brown was hung. These are the two ends of a chain
which is not without its links. He is not Old Brown any longer; his is an angel
of light.
(Read to the citizens of
Concord, Mass., Sunday Evening, October 30, 1859.)
Richmond "Whig"
Newspaper Editorial
Though it convert the whole Northern people, without an exception, into
furious, armed abolition invaders, yet
old Brown will be hung! That is
the stern and irreversible decree, not only of the authorities of Virginia, but
of the PEOPLE of Virginia, without a dissenting voice. And, therefore,
Virginia, and the people of Virginia, will treat with the contempt they
deserve, all the craven appeals of Northern men in behalf of old Brown's
pardon. The miserable old traitor and murderer belongs to the gallows,
and the gallows will have its own
(Richmond
"Whig" newspaper editorial quoted in the "Liberator", Nov.
18, 1859. From "John Brown: a Biography," by Oswald Villard)
John Brown Writes From
Jail
Charlestown, Jefferson County, VA, Nov. 1, 1859
My Dear Friend E. B. of R. I. :
You know that Christ once armed Peter. So also in my case, I think he put a
sword into my hand, and there continued it, so long as he saw best, and then
kindly took it from me. I mean when I first went to Kansas. I wish you could
know with what cheerfulness I am now wielding the "Sword of the
Spirit" on the right hand and on the left. I bless God that it proves
"mighty to the pulling down of strongholds." I always loved my Quaker
friends, and I commend to their kind regard my poor, bereaved widowed wife, and
my daughters and daughters-in-law, whose husbands fell at my side. One is a
mother and the other likely to become so soon. They, as well as my own
sorrow-stricken daughter[s], are left very poor, and have much greater need of
sympathy than I, who, through Infinite Grace and the kindness of strangers, am
"joyful in all my tribulations."
Your friend,
John Brown
(From "John Brown: a Biography," by Oswald Villard)
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/amex/brown/filmmore/reference/primary/index.html
John Brown and Southern Politics.