2.1.3 Analytic Models for Plane Geometry
Printout
The
ludicrous state of solid geometry made me pass over this branch.
This section lists analytic models that will be used in the study of plane geometry. The models are to help to better understand the axioms for neutral geometry (Euclidean geometry and hyperbolic geometry). As we progress through the SMSG axiom set, a model will be dropped when it no longer satisfies the axioms in use.
Definition. A distance function on a set S is a function such that for all
i. d(A,B) 0;
ii. d(A,B) = 0 if and only if A = B;
iii. d(A,B) = d (B,A).
Here, we do not list the Triangle Inequality as part of the definition of a distance function, since other axioms will give us the Triangle Inequality as a theorem.
Discrete Planes. Let S be a nonempty set. The points are the elements of S. The lines are a specified collection of nonempty subsets of S. The distance function is defined by
.
Riemann Sphere. The points are elements of the unit sphere .
The lines
are great circles, G, of the unit
sphere S2 formed by the
intersection of S2 and a plane through the origin; that is, there
are not all zero such that G = {(x, y, z)
ϵ S2 : ax +
by + cz = 0}. Click here for a
java exploration of the Riemann Sphere model.
Modified Riemann Sphere.
The points, {(x, y, z), (–x,
–y, –z)}, are polar pairs (antipodal points) on
the unit sphere .
The lines
are the modification of the great circles of the Riemann Sphere. In the
illustration of a sphere on the right, the Modified Riemann Sphere has three
points A, B, and C. Each polar pair of points (antipodal points) is considered to be a single point.
Also, three lines are shown, line AB,
line AC, and line BC, which consist of the great circles
passing through the polar point pairs. The segments connecting the polar points
and the center of the sphere are not in the plane determined by the Modified
Riemann Sphere; they are only drawn to help with visualization of the polar
pairs. In some sense, the Modified Riemann Sphere may be thought of as a
hemisphere with half of the equator.
Cartesian Plane. A point is an ordered pair (x, y) where , i.e. is the set of all points. The lines are either vertical la = {(x, y) : x = a} or nonvertical lm,b = {(x, y) : y = mx + b}. Note that these are the definitions for points and lines used in high school algebra.
Euclidean Plane. The points and lines for the Euclidean plane are the Cartesian points and lines with the addition of a distance function defined by
The standard ruler, ,
for a nonvertical line is defined by
The standard
ruler, ,
for a vertical line is defined by f(a, y) = y.
The angle
measure of is defined by where is the dot product (inner product) of the two
vectors and is the magnitude of the vector. Note the
definition for angle measure is motivated from results in vector calculus or
linear algebra. Check your textbooks from those two courses.
Geometer's Sketchpad sketch with tools to explore ruler's in the Euclidean, Taxicab, and Max-Distance planes is available in Appendix B of the Course Title Page - Prepared Geometer's Sketchpad and GeoGebra Sketches.
Taxicab Plane. The points and lines for the Taxicab plane are the Cartesian points and lines with the addition of a distance function defined by
.
The standard ruler, ,
for a nonvertical line is defined by f(x, y) = (1 + |m|)x.
The standard
ruler, ,
for a vertical line is defined by f(a, y) = y.
Max-Distance Plane. The points and lines for the Max-distance plane are the Cartesian points and lines with the addition of a distance function defined by
.
The standard ruler, ,
for a nonvertical line is defined by .
The standard
ruler, ,
for a vertical line is defined by f(a, y) = y.
Missing Strip Plane. A point
is an element of the set .
The lines
are modified Cartesian lines; a line is defined by a Cartesian line intersected
with set M (explore Missing Strip lines
GeoGebra html5 or
JavaSketchpad), i.e. the lines are elements of the
set .
The distance
function for two points on a vertical line is defined by the
Euclidean distance between the two points. The distance
function for two points on a nonvertical line is defined by where and gl
is defined from the standard
ruler
fl of the Euclidean plane by
where m is the
slope of line l. Note the Missing
Strip plane is simply the Euclidean plane with a vertical strip removed and all
the necessary adjustments so that no distance is measured across the missing
region. In the diagram on the right, the light blue region (river through a
town) is not part of the plane.
A prepared Geometer's Sketchpad
sketch and GeoGebra sketch with tools for constructions in the Missing Strip
plane are available in
Appendix
B of the Course Title Page -
Prepared Geometer's Sketchpad
and GeoGebra Sketches.
Poincaré Half-Plane. The points are the elements of the set , i.e. the upper half-plane of the Cartesian plane. The lines are of two types: vertical rays which are any subset of H of the form , called Type I lines; or semicircles which are any subset of H of the form , called Type II lines (explore Poincaré lines GeoGebra html5 or JaveSketchpad). The distance function is defined by
.
The standard ruler, ,
for a Type I line is defined by f(a, y) = ln y.
The standard
ruler, ,
for a Type II line is defined by .
Angle measure
for is defined by where for the ray BA the vector
TBA
is defined by
Click for a GeoGebra
html5
or javasketchpad illustration of lines in the Poincaré Half-plane.
Click for a
GeoGebra html5
or javasketchpad illustration of lines in the Missing
Strip plane.
Click for a
GeoGebra html5
or javasketchpad
illustration of angle measure in the Poincaré Half-plane.
A prepared
Geometer's Sketchpad sketch and GeoGebra sketch with tools for constructions in the Poincaré Half-plane
is available in Appendix B of the Course Title Page -
Prepared Geometer's
Sketchpad and GeoGebra Sketches. Also, an on-line java based program called
NonEuclid may
be used for constructions in the Poincaré Half-plane at
http://cs.unm.edu/~joel/NonEuclid.
Another model used for hyperbolic
geometry is the Poincaré Disk. A prepared sketch for the Poincaré Disk comes
with Geometer's Sketchpad. It is located in the Geometer's Sketchpad program
folder: Samples Sketches Investigations. Also,
NonEuclid contains the Poincaré Disk model.
Proposition 2.1. The Euclidean distance function is a distance
function.
Proof. Let (x1, y1) and (x2, y2) be points in the Euclidean plane. We need to
show the dE satisfies the
three conditions defining a distance function.
Condition (1). We have and .
Hence, .
Thus condition (1) is satisfied.
Condition (2). dE((x1, y1), (x2, y2))
= 0 iff iff (x2
– x1)2
+ (y2 – y1)2 = 0 iff (x2 – x1)2 = 0
and (y2 – y1)2 = 0 iff
x2 – x1 = 0 and y2 – y1 = 0 iff
x2
= x1 and
y2 =
y1 iff (x1, y1) = (x2, y2).
Thus condition (2) is satisfied.
Condition (3).
Thus condition (3) is satisfied.
Hence the Euclidean distance
function is a distance function. //
Exercise 2.3. For each model (Euclidean, Taxicab, Max-distance, Missing-Strip, and Poincaré Half-plane), find the distance between points P(–1, 2) and Q(3, 4).
Exercise 2.4. Show the Taxicab distance satisfies the definition of distance.
Exercise 2.5. Show the Max-distance distance satisfies the definition of distance.
Exercise 2.6. Show the Missing Strip distance satisfies the definition of distance.
Exercise 2.7. Show the Poincaré Half-plane distance satisfies the definition of distance.
Exercise 2.8. (a) Show the Hamming distance satisfies the definition of distance. (b) Does the Discrete Plane distance satisfy the definition of distance? Justify.
Exercise 2.9. Define a distance function for the Modified Riemann Sphere.
Exercise
2.10. Sketch and describe a circle for each model.
© Copyright 2005, 2006 - Timothy Peil |